Back to Top

He Thought They Would Believe it was Self-Defense (They Didn't)

This true crime police interrogation covers a man named John Allender. He and his wife would begin to have marital problems and tensions would boil. His wife Cheryl would end up dead. The police don’t quite buy into John’s version of events. 0:00 A Blended Family’s Unraveling 0:44 Living Under an Uneasy Truce 1:12 A Dispute Over Mowing the Lawn 1:44 Seeking Protection from the Law 3:29 The Detective Begins the Interview 5:29 Walking Through the Final Hours 11:03 The Complexity of Blended Custody 23:12 The Moment the Story Falls Apart 26:58 The Decision to Use Lethal Force 33:26 The Mystery of the Missing Weapon

Comments

@TheyCAUGHTme says:

*If this made up for the poor audio case from yesterday… put "YOU MADE UP FOR IT" down below* 🙂
Thank you so much for all of you who routinely support our channel. In a sea of true crime channels, you really make us feel special. Thank you!
If you would like to assist us outside of the normal liking, commenting, hyping and sharing, consider doing so right here – buymeacoffee.com/TheyCAUGHTme
(It helps us buy even more of this footage for you)

@daniellegaines35810 says:

I love this detective! He made him feel similar with the martial arts, didn’t agree with him per se but acknowledged him, and kept it soft, relaxed, and relatable. I love him!!!

@daniellegaines35810 says:

Since you made a boo boo you have to now release the merchandise early to make up for it. Just saying ❤

@charisse2795 says:

“She kind of won today” 😅

@Mrs_Garrison_05 says:

1:36:35 “a kick in the balls”🤣

@juliecurtis5122 says:

Ty for all your hard worķ yet again, liked & shared in the u.k……

@Mrs.Stone99 says:

Awesome detective. He's a great listener and he's very disarming…like all the good ones are.

@aliinwonderland656 says:

Also how was he supposing she was going to be able to refinance anything with a part time job?

@Mrs.Stone99 says:

He didnt think that epo through very well. After that he wouldnt be able to go into her part of the house either.

But the reason he ran and got it was because he was thinking about shooting her and it would help his story. Makes me think he thought he might shoot his ex wives too.

@CafeSnowflake says:

You are the best,most personal, and accountable in this Genre ,im here because i also find the psychology fascinating!!

@Mrs_Garrison_05 says:

1:25:14 you’re funny, ha!

@Mrs_Garrison_05 says:

1:20:00 “you gotta piss in a bucket”🪣🤣

@Maureen-z7q says:

Yes, they're both responsible for all the kids now.

@Max-Harden says:

"John that's not me, it's everybody"

@TravisBarker-w6e says:

Definitely made up for it

@Panona says:

His whisper voice is so creepy! And absolutely fake!!

@rmeredithm says:

11:47 – yes bc in the eyes of the law, the kids are as good as biologically hers….

@LizzHarrington says:

1 hour 10mins for me lol

@sietesamurais says:

Just started watching and my first thought was that’s no way to live! Having access to the bathroom and kitchen? Oh boy

@darcyt6650 says:

I’d rather kick back and watch grass grow than listen to this guy talk. (Edit- I’m sorry my comments not very nice)

Write a comment

*